Compare and Contrast
I’d just like to contrast two parts of the speech that Gove made (taken from the online document, not sure how closely he stuck to the script) at the Spectator Conference. I promise, after this I’m sticking to pedagogy for a bit, I’ve had enough of politics.
Michael Gove faced criticism from an unexpected source yesterday; his own speech to the Spectator Conference. In this he condemned those who used ‘alternative’ qualifications to exaggerate claims of performance or improvement, before quoting them himself.
For a decade now we have steered hundreds of thousands of young people towards courses and qualifications which are called vocational even though employers don’t rate them and which have been judged to be equivalent in league tables to one – or sometimes more – GCSEs, even though no-one really imagines they were in any way equivalent.
Adults who wanted to keep their positions, and keep their schools’ league table positions, used these qualifications to inflate their schools’ performance in these tables.
Later on, Gove praised several academies as part of his lead up to launching a funding boost for groups that take on ‘sponsor’ status.
…another Harris school – South Norwood – where 29% of pupils reached that measure [5 GCSEs at A*-C] in its last year as an LEA school; 100% last year.
The figures for 2011 he didn’t mention tell a very interesting story.
- 75% of students achieved 5 GCSEs at A*-C including English and Maths.
- 2% of students achieved the English Baccalaureate.
- 46% of students achieved 5 GCSEs if we exclude ‘equivalent’ qualifications.
So if you discount the qualifications which Gove stated are in no way equivalent, his example is rather less impressive than he would like.
I notice that at the quoted school, the ‘average student’ is entered for 6 GCSE subjects, but has a total of 13.9 entries – that’s a lot of equivalents. These figures are from the BBC website, checked where possible at the DfE listing for the school (which interestingly does not list percentage results without equivalents.)
Please let’s be clear, this is not a condemnation, or even a criticism, of a specific school. Many schools have been encouraged – effectively forced – to change their entry patterns in order to boost league table scores, due to political pressure. This has also been seen with the EBacc so Gove can’t blame it on previous governments.
Filed under: blognews, exams, teaching | 5 Comments
Tags: academies, gove, statistics